1. Home
  2. Asia
  3. Pakistan

"At least someone can come and listen to our pain"

Communities camp out in the open in Makli, a town 200km south of Karachi
(Jaspreet Kindra/IRIN)

"The water is coming!" was the cry in the streets of Thatta, about 200km east of Karachi, as shutters came down on shops. Wives, children and a few belongings were packed into vehicles and sent off to neighbouring Makli in the hills a few kilometres above the threatened city. Merchants closed their shops and did what they could to strengthen their doors against water and thieves.

On 28 August, water gushing out of one of more than 10 breaches in the embankment containing the Indus River entered a suburb of Thatta, a town of around 200,000 inhabitants, a huge port on the Arabian sea where the river debouches.

By evening the town was quiet, with very few people still around; two old men sat gossiping in a lane, confident that the Indus would not rise that high. When morning came, the flow of the water had slowed because some of it had been diverted, but no one was certain that the danger had passed.

More tragedy

A bigger tragedy has been unfolding in Makli, which usually houses about 30,000 people. In the past week hundreds of thousands from Thatta have sought shelter with friends and relatives in Makli, and 100,000-150,000 people have fled their drowning villages in the district and moved into every available space.

They all need food and water. Hundreds of people line the main roads, waiting for a private donor's vehicle with flour or water to pass by; everyone scrambles for the few bags that are tossed out and the scene quickly turns violent. "We have become like animals, but hunger brings out the worst in every being," said a displaced man watching a fight with tears in his eyes.

Every bottle of water and bag of food is fought over; people get hurt every day. Last week a woman died after one such tussle. "I don't like what I am doing but I have to do it – we will run out of flour in two days and I have to feed my children," said Rahim Dino, who survived a gash in his head but lost his bag of flour.

The donors toss bottles and food out as they drive around, and desperate people run after the vehicles. "We are not dogs – I tell my children not to go out onto the road – rather we die," said Allah Rakha, who fled his village three days ago.

Politicians arrive, look around, and drive away. There are very few tents, and some are aligned to political parties. Police and soldiers watch the crowd but no one seems to be in charge. Men, women, children and babies sit on the ground under open sky in the rain and heat; many succumb to exhaustion as the temperature climbs above 30 degrees Celsius.

The inhabitants of Makli have never seen so many people - they are in the grounds of the hospital, in the park, even in the graveyard. "This is like it was when Pakistan and India were partitioned and we had refugees," an older resident remarked.

Zohuar Khan, who drove my taxi from Karachi, has never witnessed such destitution. "This is the end," he says in disbelief. There are 15 people from his village staying in his one-room house in Karachi.

''There is nothing here – we know we will die if we stay longer – no one is giving us any food''

On the way to Makli a man and a woman have collapsed at the roadside but families squatting nearby share their tiny reserves of sugar and salt to make a solution to help rehydrate the woman. Zohuar and Asghar Ali, an official from Sindh Radiant, a local NGO, help them into the taxi and take them to the nearest mobile clinic a few kilometres away.

"The crisis has just broken in southern Sindh [where Thatta is located] and is still unfolding. Even with limited resources we have managed to stabilize the situation in the north," said Fawad Hussain of the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA), which is coordinating the NGO response in Sindh Province in southern Pakistan.


Hussain said he did not have the resources to respond, but noted that UN agencies were also overwhelmed. He has managed to secure 10,000 tents, which "I know is too little, but can provide shelter to at least 50,000 people - the tents should get there [Makli] in a day or two," he told IRIN.

He said the politicization of aid was another issue that should be addressed. "In terms of humanitarian aid principles, if political parties establish any relief effort they have to do it `on non-political grounds'".

Makli is filled with heart-breaking sights: malnourished women trying to breastfeed their babies, little children chewing on pieces flat bread made of rice flour. Most of the displaced people were paddy farmers in the Indus river delta. "Rice is all we had, and we are running out," said one mother, shaking her almost empty flour tin.

More Pakistan flooding
 Floods worsen malnutrition
 Reaching flood victims by truck, mule and chopper
 Flood damaged schools lead to education worries
 Poorest hit by floods/Ramadan woes

Help is on the way. Irfan Malik, programme officer at the World Food Programme (WFP) in Sindh, said they were awaiting reports from their assessment team and would start food distribution in Thatta District in a day or two, but the scale of the disaster would make it difficult to cater to everyone's needs immediately.

In the first phase WFP will provide aid to about 330,000 of the estimated 1.8 million people so far affected in Sindh - the numbers are climbing as flooding continues. More than 20 million people have been affected by the floods in a disaster described as the "worst ever" in this part of the world.

On 29 August, several families are packing their belongings as I prepare to leave. "There is nothing here – we know we will die if we stay longer – no one is giving us any food," said Sher Mohammed.

"We will wait for someone to give us a lift to, maybe, Karachi – we understand there are camps there." Most of the displaced families have used all their savings to pay for transport out of their water-logged villages to Makli. "Everyone has made money out of the floods – vehicle owners, shopkeepers who have hiked up the prices of food and even bottled water," he said.

Ghulam Hussain Khwaja, president of Sindh Radiant, said Thatta District was one of the most disaster-prone areas in Pakistan. A seismic fault line runs through the area, and the coastal areas are vulnerable to floods and cyclones. "Communities often get displaced, and yet we do not have a permanent strategy in place," he commented.

His father, Iqbal Khwaja, a veteran journalist and a correspondent for Dawn, a national daily, said the authorities needed to act promptly to redeem the people's faith and trust in public institutions.

As I leave Makli the taxi is mobbed by desperate and sometimes angry people looking for any kind of aid. "Koi aake humhara dukh dard hi soon le [At least someone can come and listen to our pain]," says a displaced woman, wiping the sweat off her face.


This article was produced by IRIN News while it was part of the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs. Please send queries on copyright or liability to the UN. For more information: https://shop.un.org/rights-permissions

Share this article
Join the discussion

We uncovered the sex abuse scandal that rocked the WHO, but there’s more to do

We just covered a report that says the World Health Organization failed to prevent and tackle widespread sexual abuse during the Ebola response in Congo.

Our investigation with the Thomson Reuters Foundation triggered this probe, demonstrating the impact our journalism can have. 

But this won’t be the last case of aid worker sex abuse. This also won’t be the last time the aid sector has to ask itself difficult questions about why justice for victims of sexual abuse and exploitation has been sorely lacking. 

We’re already working on our next investigation, but reporting like this takes months, sometimes years, and can’t be done alone. 

The support of our readers and donors helps keep our journalism free and accessible for all. Donations mean we can keep holding power in the aid sector accountable, and do more of this. 

Become a member today and support independent journalism

Become a member of The New Humanitarian

Support our journalism and become more involved in our community. Help us deliver informative, accessible, independent journalism that you can trust and provides accountability to the millions of people affected by crises worldwide.