The rollout of universal health coverage in Indonesia has been greeted with public enthusiasm, but health experts warn that inadequate funding could undermine the quality of care.
The government aims to have every Indonesian covered by health insurance by 2019 under a new scheme called Jaminan Kesehatan Nasional (JKN), with nearly 20 trillion rupiah (US$1.6 billion) allocated to cover premiums for the poor in 2014.
Around 65 percent of the country’s 240 million people, including 86 million categorized as poor, are covered by some form of regional or national health programme and are automatically entitled to comprehensive coverage under the JKN, which has replaced the previous health schemes.
“This is a great programme. It should mean that people will no longer be denied treatment because they don’t have money,” said Wawan Mulyawan, a neurosurgeon and medical insurance consultant who works at a private hospital in Jakarta, the capital.
The World Bank estimates the insurance scheme will cost $13-$16 billion each year once fully implemented, while Jakarta has said it will double its spending on health to 16 trillion rupiah ($1.64 billion) in 2014 to cover the poor and “near poor”.
Challenges and concerns
The rollout began on 1 January 2014, but implementation has not gone smoothly, with many workers at referral hospitals poorly informed about the programme’s details.
“Hospitals are afraid they will lose money by not being reimbursed like in the past, while health workers are afraid they will make mistakes,” Mulyawan conceded. “As a result, quality of treatment has been compromised because it doesn’t follow clinical pathways set by the hospitals.”
Under the previous national insurance for the poor, hospitals, both state and private, complained the government delayed payments for more than a year, and some hospitals refused patients unless they made partial payment in advance. However, the government says it has learned from its mistakes.
“We are strengthening the primary care system across the country by improving infrastructure and adding more health workers,” Deputy Health Minister Ali Ghufran told IRIN.
Indonesia has 25 health workers per 10,000 people, which meets the World Health Organization's minimum of 23, but they tend to be concentrated in urban centres, leaving parts of the archipelago without an adequate number of health personnel.
More than 1,700 state and private hospitals are participating in JKN, with over 9,000 state-funded community clinics, known as Puskesmas, serving as the backbone of primary care, Ghufran said.
The government plans to build 150 new hospitals in 2014, and says all hospitals will be required to serve JKN patients by 2019.
People’s welfare minister Agung Laksono said the challenges facing the health system in implementing universal coverage include a poorly functioning referral system, poor quality services at primary and referral levels, and high treatment costs.
Patient safety is also a concern, as not all hospitals are accredited, he said. Only around 65 percent of Indonesia’s hospitals are accredited, with the majority of them being state-run.
The new Banda Aceh General Hospital has state of the art equipment, but still has to refer patients abroad for specialised care
“Indonesia is undergoing a transition in disease epidemiology, marked by the still high prevalence of communicable diseases, and yet at the same time degenerative and non-communicable diseases such as cardiovascular diseases and cancer are on the increase,” he said.
The rate of mortality from non-communicable diseases rose from 41.7 percent in 1995 to 59.5 percent in 2007 - an increase of 42 percent - the latest figure available from the Health Ministry.
According to the Health Ministry's Basic Health Survey, the prevalence of diabetes was 2.1 percent in 2013, compared to 1.1 percent in 2007. Hypertension was prevalent among 31.7 percent of the population, up from 25.8 percent in 2007.
A report released in 2013 by Novo Nordisk, a global healthcare company, says 7.6 million people in Indonesia are living with diabetes, with millions more are at risk.
By 2030, the number of people with diabetes in Indonesia is projected to top 11.8 million, a 6 percent annual growth that by far exceeds the country’s overall population growth.
Muhammad Imran, whose elderly father was receiving treatment for diabetes and high blood pressure as an outpatient under a previous insurance plan, said the Central Army Hospital had been inundated with patients referred by primary healthcare clinics.
“My father had to wait for hours to be seen by a doctor,” he said. “After that we had to queue again for hours at the pharmacy. This is ridiculous.”
While the government pays 19,225 Indonesian rupiah ($1.60) per month for treatment in a third-class hospital ward for each poor citizen, individuals can also purchase one of three insurance options: 25,500 rupiah ($2) per month for third-class treatment, 42,500 rupiah ($3.60) for second-class and 59,000 rupiah ($5) for first-class.
The 110,000-member Indonesian Medical Association says the amount the government is paying for the poor is too low, and has warned that this could compromise the quality of healthcare.
What about the doctors?
“There will inevitably be problems. Doctors will not be adequately paid and they won’t be able to provide the maximum quality of care,” said association chairman Zainal Abidin.
Indonesian President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono said he was aware of the potential problem, and the government would issue an additional regulation providing financial incentives for doctors and other medical workers. The premium paid for the poor would also gradually be increased.
“An evaluation will be conducted after three months, and [again after] six months, to ensure that its implementation will be better in the future,” the president said.
The JKN specifies that government doctors and dentists working at public clinics (Pukesmas) be paid according to “capitation”, meaning that healthcare providers are paid a set amount for each enrolled person assigned to them during a period of time (usually a month), whether or not that person seeks treatment.
Under the programme, doctors and health facilities at the primary care level, both public and private, will have to treat all persons assigned to them, regardless of whether patients come to them for treatment or not.
But Abidin said the amount a primary care provider or family doctor receives for each enrolled person assigned to them - 8,000 rupiah, about 68 US cents - is too low.
For example, public and private clinics or family doctors will receive 40 million rupiah ($3,328) for 5,000 enrolled citizens in advance per month, regardless of how much they spend on treating those patients, and whether or not they seek care.
According to a 2013 paper by Australia’s Nossal Institute for Global Health, there were potential inequalities in implementing universal health coverage in Indonesia.
Experience with the previous national health scheme, Jamkesmas, had shown that despite nominal comprehensive coverage for the poor, patients had difficulty accessing certain services, and sometimes had to pay for medicines not available at the facility, particularly in rural areas.
“Poor quality and unequal distribution of government health facilities have been issues with which the ministry of health has been struggling with for some decades, without much progress. Significant further government investment in health infrastructure and workforce will be needed,” the paper said.
The Health Ministry says Indonesia needs more than 12,000 new doctors to meet its goal of 40 per 100,000 people. The country has 88,000 doctors, with a ratio of 33 doctors per 100,000 people, and its universities produce 7,000 doctors annually, the ministry noted.
“The majority of doctors are civil servants. If there’s a surge in patients while... [the doctor] has to juggle working in two or three places to make a decent living, you can imagine the stress,” said Mulyawan, the neurosurgeon and insurance expert.
The unequal distribution of health workers would not be a problem if they were adequately paid wherever they work, he said. “Most doctors choose to work in cities because that’s where the money is.”
This article was produced by IRIN News while it was part of the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs. Please send queries on copyright or liability to the UN. For more information: https://shop.un.org/rights-permissions
It was The New Humanitarian’s investigation with the Thomson Reuters Foundation that uncovered sexual abuse by aid workers during the Ebola response in the Democratic Republic of Congo and led the World Health Organization to launch an independent review and reform its practices.
This demonstrates the important impact that our journalism can have.
But this won’t be the last case of aid worker sex abuse. This also won’t be the last time the aid sector has to ask itself difficult questions about why justice for victims of sexual abuse and exploitation has been sorely lacking.
We’re already working on our next investigation, but reporting like this takes months, sometimes years, and can’t be done alone.
The support of our readers and donors helps keep our journalism free and accessible for all. Donations mean we can keep holding power in the aid sector accountable, and shine a light on similar abuses.