1. Home
  2. Middle East and North Africa
  3. Palestine

Egyptian steel barrier tests Gazan mettle

A worker descends into a tunnel near Rafah, southern Gaza. Egypt has nearly finished constructing a metal wall along its border with Gaza in an attempt to stop smuggling via tunnels
Un travailleur descend dans un tunnel près de Rafah, au sud de Gaza. L’Égypte a presque terminé la construction d’un mur métallique le long de sa frontière avec Gaza pour essayer d’en finir avec la contrebande par les tunnels (Suhair Karam/IRIN)

Egypt’s imminent completion of an above-and-below-ground steel barrier along its border with the Gaza Strip is putting Gazans on edge: How will they survive without the huge trade conducted via underground tunnels?

A lucrative tunnel smuggling trade in a range of commodities took off after Israel imposed an economic embargo on the Strip after a Hamas takeover in June 2007. The World Bank and Palestinian economists estimate that at least 80 percent of Gaza's total imports come through the tunnels.

“Digging tunnels and working in them is one of the few jobs available for Palestinian youth in Gaza,” Omar Sha’ban, a Gazan economist, said.

“Tunnel workers reportedly earn US$25 per day, a huge sum in the current Palestinian economy. However, they are subjected to daily bombings… by the Israeli Air Force, tunnel collapses and fires.”

Ziad al-Zaza, economy minister in the Hamas government, said there were some 20,000 tunnel workers before Israel’s military operation in Gaza in early 2009, and about half that number now. The Israeli military said it damaged or destroyed 60-70 percent of the tunnels in the offensive.

Tunnel owner and manager Abu Antar*, 45, said an end to the tunnels between Gaza and Rafah in Egypt would mean no income for him and thousands of others who rely on the tunnels for work. 

More on Gaza
 Why violence against women is widespread
 Uphill battle to supply prosthetics to Gaza war injured
 Gaza fishermen under fire
 Gaza schoolchildren struggling to learn
 Psychological trauma, nightmares stalk Gaza children
 PHOTO GALLERY: Mud brick houses in Gaza

“We have succeeded in cutting through the Egyptian fence, but the thing we are afraid of now is that the Egyptians will electrify it and add seismic sensors to detect us underground, which would make our mission impossible. Tunnels are our only source of living,” the father of seven told IRIN.

Egypt’s steel barrier will be 10-11km long and will extend 18 metres below ground on completion, the Egyptian authorities have said. Egyptian daily al-Shorouq recently reported that “work on the main wall is in its fourth and final stage," after which cameras and detection devices will be installed.

It is believed this process will take a few weeks and then will undergo a testing period before becoming fully operational.

Dangerous work

Abu Antar said the tunnel he owns has 50 people working in it.

“Every day we work in the tunnels and wonder if we’ll get out alive. Many times the earth has collapsed… Death is inevitable in this type of work. We are dealing with fear 24 hours a day. Many people have died. Every month there are more causalities in the tunnels from the continuous [Israeli] air strikes,” he said.

Accidents in the tunnels are frequent. According to Palestinian human rights organization Al-Mezan, 120 tunnel traders have been killed over the past three years.

Tunnel workers estimate there are over 1,000 tunnels between Gaza and the town of Rafah on the Egyptian side of the border - dug at depths of 15-35m and up to 1km long.

Palestine Square in Gaza City during Ramadan. Food insecurity is affecting Ramadan meals in the Gaza Strip as residents struggle to find and afford traditional Ramadan foods

Palestine Square in Gaza City during Ramadan
Erica Silverman/IRIN
Palestine Square in Gaza City during Ramadan. Food insecurity is affecting Ramadan meals in the Gaza Strip as residents struggle to find and afford traditional Ramadan foods
Sunday, August 30, 2009
La barrière métallique égyptienne teste les nerfs des habitants de Gaza
Palestine Square in Gaza City during Ramadan. Food insecurity is affecting Ramadan meals in the Gaza Strip as residents struggle to find and afford traditional Ramadan foods

Photo: Erica Silverman/IRIN
Palestine Square in Gaza City. At least 80 percent of Gaza's total imports come through tunnels

“Humanitarian disaster”

“A tunnel costs around 200,000 US dollars [to build], so when these tunnels get destroyed by Israeli planes, or when they are blocked by the Egyptian wall, poverty and unemployment will go up and up,” he said. “Blocking the tunnels will lead to a huge humanitarian disaster. All residents of the Gaza Strip will then rely on UN food aid,” said Hamas minister al-Zaza.

“We call on the Egyptian and Israel governments to lift the siege imposed on Gaza and let Palestinians work on the ground, not underground, and let Gazans live with dignity and pride,” al-Zaza said.

Israel imposed severe import restrictions on the Gaza Strip after the Hamas takeover in 2007 and in retaliation for the firing of rockets from Gaza into Israel. The import ban affects everything which could conceivably help Hamas develop weapons, including iron, steel and most building materials. All exports are banned and imports are confined to a limited supply of humanitarian goods. Items such as school text books, desks, medical equipment, household goods and shelter kits face huge delays.

Israel has praised Egyptian efforts to combat smuggling. Egypt says its security was under threat by an increasing flow of illicit goods and militants through the tunnels to its territory.

Israel accuses Hamas of using the tunnels to bring in weapons, a charge Hamas denies.

On a tour of Gaza earlier this month, UN Emergency Relief Coordinator John Holmes warned of big problems if the tunnels were successfully blocked.

"If those tunnels were blocked, however undesirable they may be, and however undesirable the effect they're having on the Gazan society and Gazan economy, the situation without the tunnels would be completely unsustainable," Holmes said. He repeated calls for Israel to end its blockade of the Palestinian territory.

*Not his real name


This article was produced by IRIN News while it was part of the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs. Please send queries on copyright or liability to the UN. For more information: https://shop.un.org/rights-permissions

Share this article
Join the discussion

Hundreds of thousands of readers trust The New Humanitarian each month for quality journalism that contributes to more effective, accountable, and inclusive ways to improve the lives of people affected by crises.

Our award-winning stories inform policymakers and humanitarians, demand accountability and transparency from those meant to help people in need, and provide a platform for conversation and discussion with and among affected and marginalised people.

We’re able to continue doing this thanks to the support of our donors and readers like you who believe in the power of independent journalism. These contributions help keep our journalism free and accessible to all.

Show your support as we build the future of news media by becoming a member of The New Humanitarian. 

Become a member of The New Humanitarian

Support our journalism and become more involved in our community. Help us deliver informative, accessible, independent journalism that you can trust and provides accountability to the millions of people affected by crises worldwide.